My thoughts on the songs we know about to date:
* Blue Gangsta- I think it's a strong song and would be great on the radio. The only change I can see on it is shaving the ending down a bit as it drags on.
* Slave To the Rhythm- Another strong song. I love MJ's vocals on it, especially towards the end where it sounds like MJ's really getting into it.
* A Place Without No Name- Even though we only have a 20+ second clip, it sounds great. Can't wait to hear the rest.
* Do You Know Where Your Children Are- A great song with a controversial topic. Not a good choice for a single, but should be released on album.
* Love Never Felt So Good- It's ok. Nothing special. I see this being released on an album anniversary release.
* Why- if a solo version of this truly exists, I will crap my pants. I love this song..and I think it would be a great song to close the next album with (kind of like "Much Too Soon" for the Michael album)....MJ's voice trailing off singing "tell me why?" is the perfect way to end an album IMO.
^
It won't be coming out in 2012, but Bad 25 and the Bad Tour DVD will.
^^ A solo version of 'Why' DOES exist! :wild:
For The Record 2nd Edition:
Why:
Completed solo version believed not to exist, as 3T's Taj has confirmed he and his brothers only ever heard Babyface's demo version, before recording the song.
Maybe Cascio has it somewhere in his vault entirely sung by "Michael".
AndreyZidane™;3303734 said:Why are you putting him down for providing what many (including me) consider "facts" (info from For The Record)?
Also, a producer (I forget which one) on Gearslutz said that MJ never recorded 'Why'.
I reckon Michael does have a version of "Why" with just his solo vocals, Taj said that he only heard Babyfaces version, so they wouldn't know if Michael recorded it then, would they. Maybe Michael didn't like the demo with just his voice, or maybe he recorded it later after with the group, but this song was considered for HIStory and it was 3T who asked Michael if they could have the song.
Yes but it's likely that if 3T heard the Babyface demo before they took the song that Michael didn't record a solo version, because he probably would have played them that if he did. He wasn't playing them songs that they might like he was playing them contenders for HIStory - so it's likely that he would have played them his own version.
Why would Michael record a solo version after giving the song to 3T?
From "For The Record":
WHY
Song written by Kenneth ‘Babyface’ Edmonds, and originally scheduled to appear on Michael’s album, HISTORY – until his three nephews, 3T (Tito’s sons Taj, Taryll and TJ) claimed it.
‘The song was supposed to be on Michael’s HISTORY album, but we loved it so much that we kinda ended up stealing it from him,’ confirmed TJ in early 1996. ‘I mean, once he played it for us and saw our faces he was like, “You guys want this song?” – and that’s exactly what happened, and working in the studio with him was such an experience.’
Recorded by 3T, as a duet with Michael, for their debut album, BROTHERHOOD, released in 1996.
Michael didn’t actually record the song with his nephews, but allowed them to use his original version of the song, and turn it into a collaboration by adding their own vocals
Hit no.2 in the UK, but struggled to no.71 on the R&B singles chart in the States, and only managed no.112 on the ‘bubbling under’ section of the Hot 100.
Promo short film featured Michael and his nephews – Michael, with Ralph Ziman, also directed.
Official Versions:
Album Version.
D.W. Bonus Mix.
Radio Edit.
362
Solo version by Michael remains unreleased
If it was removed from For The Record for the 2nd edition, they must have found out they made a mistake and fixed it.
Oooo I hope this is true. I was gutted when A Place With No Name wasn't on "Michael"
What is Gearslutz?
What is Gearslutz?
It is the same as Gearstreetwalker or Gearprostitute, but in a more familiar context. I'd say that the synonym would be something like Gearbiatch.
Same here, the vocals on that song sound AMAZING... I just hope when Dr.Freeze said he has changed it slightly, I hope he hasn't renewed it.