Just want to point out, this is pretty close to what it would have been like had Michael had paid EC immediately in '93. Settling was the smart move here but unfortunately this really is a lose-lose situation looks-wise, but it's better that they handled their claims ASAP rather then let them go public, because that would have, as everyone is saying, been the nail in the coffin.
But:
Given that the estate is 100% on the offensive now and putting this stuff out there for all to see, highlighting that it is extortion, I suspect this isn't as bad as we're thinking. The transparency is going to resonate with people, especially judges & a jury.
To play devil's advocate here. Say *hypothetically* that this family or some of their members did experience some form of inappropriate behavior at the hands of MJ, why would they choose silence and a quick couple million over joining in with WR and JS to call for victims to come forward and "cancel" MJ, giving more credibility to victims? The fact is that the estate was able to essentially "buy" their life story rights of alleged misconduct. This is the ringer indicating the false nature of their claims. Who would sell the rights to their story of abuse to the estate of the alleged abuser? And then come back and ask for triple the money? That's the kind of stuff that a judge is gonna see. It's the same pattern as everyone else.
Branca airing this out at the same time as they are dealing with the WR & JS suit is gonna help in the long-run to display how lied on Michael's name is for profit. It's going to help the "everyone wants a piece of the MJ money, and know the easiest way to get it" narrative that I suspect the estate is trying to set up.
Plus, if they can hold off on any further publication of these claims until after the biopic, it could help sway public opinion on these cases.
That all said, the wording of the article at a glance doesn't do great pr for the "paid off victims" thing, but I don't think they would have publicized this information unless they felt it was the right move. And say what you will about Branca and the estate release-wise, but as far as their business decisions, they have made some pretty smart decisions ($3b in 15 years is an average of roughly $200m a year). So for that reason I am a little at ease with all this. Obviously the media is going to pick-up and run this through the roof, but I think it will all work out.
I will say, I'm a little nervous about a LN2 getting put out a lot quicker, sooner, and with more claims. Hopefully the verdict for the WR & JS case blocks that in some way.
Random, Have we ruled out Blanca Francia's family? IMO the Cascios makes the most sense, but I would be unsurprised if this was the Francias again.