Roosje;3328106 said:
Do you have any statistics to back up your claim that prisons 'don't work at all'. I know a great number of people will return to crime, but many will learn their lesson and be a participating member of society again.
Forgiveness is best for your own heart, but the state can't arrange this to happen of course, whatever punishment is in place. It rather ironic though to forgive a person who has been sentenced to death already.
Prisons should be clean and livable of course. Doing a crime in return 'the same' is not justice it's mixed-up morals, that can never be state-approved. The state should protect it's citizens, not kill them or use them as laboratory animals.
I must get back my five euro from you for sure, but I must not steal them back. By the way, this analogy doesn't stretch to murder and death penalty. Where my 5 euros can be regained, the life of the murdered person will never be, whatever you do with the killer. The means to do things, to punish, are very telling about your own morality.
As you can see from this article, the reality in the Netherlands is not the same in Belgium:
<TABLE class=storycontent cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0><TBODY><TR><TD colSpan=2>
Belgium to rent Dutch jail cells
</TD></TR><TR><TD class=storybody><!-- S BO --><!-- S IIMA --><TABLE border=0 cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width=226 align=right><TBODY><TR><TD>
A warden closes the gate to Arlon prison in Belgium
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE><!-- E IIMA --><!-- S SF -->
Tight on space in its jails, Belgium will start renting 500 cells at Tilburg prison in neighbouring Netherlands. The agreement will make up for the shortage of cells across Belgium and send roughly 500 prisoners away for three years.
Belgium will pay 30m euros (£26.8m) a year for sending its detainees across the border.
No prisoners who are "an escape risk or a risk to society" will be sent to Tilburg, Dutch officials said.
<!-- E SF -->"The Netherlands is putting the prison and its personnel at Belgium's disposal for placing at least 500 detainees over a period of three years," the Dutch justice ministry said.
The prisoners will be guarded by Dutch wardens, but the prison director will be Belgian.
There are still a number of issues that need to be resolved, including how often detainees may be seen by family and friends.
In Belgium, prisoners may receive visitors three times a week, while those in the Netherlands may only receive guests once a week.
Belgium's prisons currently hold 10,400 people - nearly 2,000 more than capacity.
The Netherlands on the other hand has nearly 2,000 empty prison cells, thanks to a significant drop in crime since the beginning of this century.
The deal was signed by Belgium's Justice Minister Stefaan De Clerck and his Dutch counterpart Nebahat Albayrak.
The agreement still needs to pass both countries' parliaments.
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE><TABLE class=storycontent cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0><TBODY><TR><TD colSpan=2>
Belgium to rent Dutch jail cells
</TD></TR><TR><TD class=storybody><!-- S BO --><!-- S IIMA --><TABLE border=0 cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width=226 align=right><TBODY><TR><TD>
A warden closes the gate to Arlon prison in Belgium
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE><!-- E IIMA --><!-- S SF -->
Tight on space in its jails, Belgium will start renting 500 cells at Tilburg prison in neighbouring Netherlands. The agreement will make up for the shortage of cells across Belgium and send roughly 500 prisoners away for three years.
Belgium will pay 30m euros (£26.8m) a year for sending its detainees across the border.
No prisoners who are "an escape risk or a risk to society" will be sent to Tilburg, Dutch officials said.
<!-- E SF -->"The Netherlands is putting the prison and its personnel at Belgium's disposal for placing at least 500 detainees over a period of three years," the Dutch justice ministry said.
The prisoners will be guarded by Dutch wardens, but the prison director will be Belgian.
There are still a number of issues that need to be resolved, including how often detainees may be seen by family and friends.
In Belgium, prisoners may receive visitors three times a week, while those in the Netherlands may only receive guests once a week.
Belgium's prisons currently hold 10,400 people - nearly 2,000 more than capacity.
The Netherlands on the other hand has nearly 2,000 empty prison cells, thanks to a significant drop in crime since the beginning of this century.
The deal was signed by Belgium's Justice Minister Stefaan De Clerck and his Dutch counterpart Nebahat Albayrak.
The agreement still needs to pass both countries' parliaments.
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
Source: BBC