Open General discussion - Katherine Jackson vs AEG

Status
Not open for further replies.
Karen's email has proven what many of us have been saying since 2005 when she got fired for helping Randy steal money from us with MJJSource. She's as fake and a back stabbed like everyone else Michael had in his life.

Those videos just ripped me up inside.
 
I don't understand Prince's testimony. He said the last time he spoke with his dad was the day of Phillips visit and that was on the 24, then he said it could be the day before, that'll be the 23. So if he's linking the last talk with his dad to the visit that means Michael didn't see his children on the 24th. Does that make sense to anyone?

His testimony reminds of LaToya saying that Phillips was at Michael's house the night before he died.

Another thing that confused me was the birthday celebration, as Kai, he said Paris & Prince don't celebrate birthdays, but what about the pics of Paris's birthday celebration?
 
There is a lot I did not understand and there was a lot about it that worries me for him
 
bouee;3855289 said:
Afternoon maybe, why not, midday I don't think so. Kai Chase did not mention that in her testimony (she was not asked). She said she would work until 6.30 pm to 8.30 pm, depending on the days. When I read it, I thought it was later in the evening/night, like right nefore Michael would come back. A security cam video was played at CM's trial of the night of the 24th, I think it showed Murray arriving at Carolwood 30mn before Michael ? (not sure, will try to look it up later)

I don't think it could be evening. Murray came a believe 10 or so minutes before and the kids say they did not see Michael when he came home around 1:30 (as they were probably sleeping). So Prince seeing Randy and Murray after 1 AM, calling Michael, giving them food and going to bed before Michael comes seems to be not possible.

so I would say mid day / afternoon.

I wonder if this could be June 18. There has been a claim of a "riot meeting" - by Karen which she said Ortega came back and told her Phillips told Michael he would pull the plug. I kinda remember in criminal trial Ortega denied he was present for such meeting (but I'm not sure).


Tygger;3855309 said:
This is the correct protocol. The plaintiffs cannot simply say she is not testifying; a doctor must excuse her.

plaintiffs are in control of who they call to the stand. They don't need a doctors note to not call Paris to testify. A doctors note can only determine if AEG can call her - if they even want to.

Ivy, one of the issues in this trial is Gongaware being aware of Michael’s dependency issues in the past and how doctors’ accommodated those issues.

The issue is you are approaching it like a fact however the reality is there had been a claim of Gongaware being told about MJ's dependency issues (we are yet to see Dr. Finkelstein deposition / testimony) and Gongaware denied it. there's no way to know what will the jury will decide about what Gongaware knew or did not know.

Dr. Matheson did not suggest Michael being taken to an ER by force. He suggested an ER so Michael would be seen by a neutral doctor; one not beholden to AEG and one not controlled by Michael as Dr. Earley suggested.

So you agree that if Michael said "no", he couldn't be seen by a neutral doctor - unless of course as Dr. Metheson continues to say "Phillips said you cannot come back to rehearsals after you see a doctor" - which is a threat.

A personal doctor should be allowed to continue to treat Michael whether the tour was terminated or cancelled.

And he could have, he treated Michael for 3 years before the tour and he could have continued to treat Michael for 30 years after the tour - as long as Michael wanted him.

The only way to avoid conflict was for AEG to not deal with the doctor whatsoever except to advance monies to Michael to pay him.

Dr. Matheson disagrees with you or you disagree with him. He said such would still make Murray feel beholden to AEG.


Ivy, I will admit to being shocked by that post. I will simply say, none of this makes him an anesthesiologist.

Well you go back and re-read it you'll see there's no reason to be shocked. I never said it makes him an anesthesiologist, I talked about competency for general care. It was there, really simple to see.

If you need further clarification : some people say why Murray was hired given he was a cardiologist and Michael did not have a heart problem. My post said Murray was also an internal medicine doctor which is by all standards competent to handle general care of adults. It's a fact.

No part of my post talked about Propofol or anesthesiology in any way.


elusive moonwalker;3855311 said:
Intresting that jr confirmed the mj gave murray money via them when they were back in vegas.

not many realize that Prince created an employment between Michael and Murray long before even AEG come into the picture.
 
^^^^ It is a little confusing, and we have to remember that Prince was only a child and it was 4 years ago. Ivy confirmed that we will be getting a transcript of his testimony, it may or may not be a little clearer then.

Re the birthdays, the children always celebrated their birthday with their Dad, Prince said since his passing they don't feel like celebrating, which is a little different to Kai saying they dont celebrate.
 
Last edited:
I do wonder aswell. it sounds alot like toya theories about philips being in the house.i hope the meeting did take place at some point and jr is just confusing days. but to me its strange that he doesnt know when he last spoke to his dad because thats the way it is if hes getting days mixed up. u may mix up days but surely u remember the last time u saw or spoke. paris does. i hope jr hasnt lied for the family and or embelished things to help them win money. i presume theres other witnesses or a security log re who came on the property. whether ppl can remember exactly is another issue though. i find it strange murray denied the meeting aswell. why would he care one way or the other. i put nothing past the family but i would hope jr would have something about him to not be used by them..i guess we will see what evidence aeg have. lets hope it not something like records showing he was in meetings all day for eg

I don't understand Prince's testimony. He said the last time he spoke with his dad was the day of Phillips visit and that was on the 24, then he said it could be the day before, that'll be the 23. So if he's linking the last talk with his dad to the visit that means Michael didn't see his children on the 24th. Does that make sense to anyone?

His testimony reminds of LaToya saying that Phillips was at Michael's house the night before he died.

Another thing that confused me was the birthday celebration, as Kai, he said Paris & Prince don't celebrate birthdays, but what about the pics of Paris's birthday celebration?
 
I don't understand Prince's testimony. He said the last time he spoke with his dad was the day of Phillips visit and that was on the 24, then he said it could be the day before, that'll be the 23. So if he's linking the last talk with his dad to the visit that means Michael didn't see his children on the 24th. Does that make sense to anyone?

His testimony reminds of LaToya saying that Phillips was at Michael's house the night before he died.

Another thing that confused me was the birthday celebration, as Kai, he said Paris & Prince don't celebrate birthdays, but what about the pics of Paris's birthday celebration?
It makes perfect sense to me. Prince said Michael ate less meal with them in June. Don't forget although the children were homeschooled, they followed the school schedule strictly. 23th, 24th, Michael rehearsed in staple centre all days. When Michael woke up, his children were in class. when he went home, they slept. So it's quite normal, if prince didnt talk with his father in june 23th. he said it could be 23th, or 24th. He couldn't remember the date but remember it's the last conversation with his father. Latoya's words are the things she heard from the children. what picture of Paris celebration? A cake? What others did for you doesn't mean you want it yourself.
 
I also wonder why the judge allowed the two videos to be shown. the second was so cheesy. if thats not trying to influence the jury i dont know what is. surely things like that should only be used to help determine damages like a victim impact statemnt. not be used during the trial when its irrelevent to the actual charge and is just done to emotionally influence the jury. the judge is very slack with anything goes attitude
 
Paris said she sae and spoke to mj when he wsd leaving for rehearsal june 24t u would presume the same for all the kids?
 
loveforever;3855513 said:
It makes perfect sense to me. Prince said Michael ate less meal with them in June. Don't forget although the children were homeschooled, they followed the school schedule strictly. 23th, 24th, Michael rehearsed in staple centre all days. When Michael woke up, his children were in class. when he went home, they slept. So it's quite normal, if prince didnt talk with his father in june 23th. he said it could be 23th, or 24th. He couldn't remember the date but remember it's the last conversation with his father. Latoya's words are the things she heard from the children. what picture of Paris celebration? A cake? What others did for you doesn't mean you want it yourself.

So if it was 23rd, Michael didn’t talk to his children for two days… It’s hard to believe that Michael could take himself away from kids for so long.

Someone has said that Prince were talking about two meetings, so I think we need to wait until the transcript.

Thank you Elusive.
 
Last edited:
prince said it could be 23th, but it also could be 24th. He couldn't remember the date, but I am sure the last conversation with your only parent will stay in your mind forever that you couldn't forget. Michael's children are the only one in this case with clean hands. They have nothing to gain, money, they have plenty. The Jacksons, they have no problem calling them out. Dont forget prince's words “If you continue with your lies I will continue with the truth”. Prince even debunked chef Kai's testimony that hurts his own case. The only person with no motive in the case is Prince.
 
I also wonder why the judge allowed the two videos to be shown. the second was so cheesy. if thats not trying to influence the jury i dont know what is. surely things like that should only be used to help determine damages like a victim impact statemnt. not be used during the trial when its irrelevent to the actual charge and is just done to emotionally influence the jury. the judge is very slack with anything goes attitude
it also has the effect of showing the jury Michael as the person. How your children behave is like the mirror showing what kind of person you are.
 
It makes perfect sense to me. Prince said Michael ate less meal with them in June. Don't forget although the children were homeschooled, they followed the school schedule strictly. 23th, 24th, Michael rehearsed in staple centre all days. When Michael woke up, his children were in class. when he went home, they slept. So it's quite normal, if prince didnt talk with his father in june 23th. he said it could be 23th, or 24th. He couldn't remember the date but remember it's the last conversation with his father. Latoya's words are the things she heard from the children. what picture of Paris celebration? A cake? What others did for you doesn't mean you want it yourself.

But what about the agreement that Michael had lunch with his children?
 
It makes perfect sense to me. Prince said Michael ate less meal with them in June. Don't forget although the children were homeschooled, they followed the school schedule strictly. 23th, 24th, Michael rehearsed in staple centre all days. When Michael woke up, his children were in class. when he went home, they selot.

School that late in June?? I think Ive read the kids did not have school on June 23/24. The kids followed the curriculum/schedule of a school in LA so its safe to assume their school had ended and they were on summerbreak at that time.
 
Last edited:
It would be interesting to compile a timeline for all the events, rehearsals and emails, any volunteers? lol

20th June Phillips has growing respect for Murray (thanks bouee)

23rd June RP & murray have taken over rehearsal schedule.

24th June Michael was at rehearsals (pm) and Phillips was also there.

I'm not sure at the moment where this meeting Prince testified about fits in.

---
Murray (we don't know about RP) takes over Michael's schedule before the 20th (cf kenny at murray's trial, he said the talked about it at the forum) . I think it was a part of june 16th meeting (riot act)

--

I'll try to do the emails this week end or next week, and will let you know if I can't- It's time consuming.

From that I can begin a draft for a timeline (doing it at the same time as the e mails can be done fast, but it will be incomplete, I will need help for that)

I don't think it could be evening. Murray came a believe 10 or so minutes before and the kids say they did not see Michael when he came home around 1:30 (as they were probably sleeping). So Prince seeing Randy and Murray after 1 AM, calling Michael, giving them food and going to bed before Michael comes seems to be not possible.

so I would say mid day / afternoon.

I wonder if this could be June 18. There has been a claim of a "riot meeting" - by Karen which she said Ortega came back and told her Phillips told Michael he would pull the plug. I kinda remember in criminal trial Ortega denied he was present for such meeting (but I'm not sure).

We would need to check this video, + Kai Chase was not asked about it, so it would be after 6.30pm or 8.30 pm + it would be interesting to know if Phillips was asked about it.

Riot Act : KO said it wasn't true, that he wasn't there, and I believe him : his testimony at CM's trial fits with the events. Karen is a little mistaken : I believe (almost like 99% certain) that the riot act was the june 16th meeting that we talked bout earlier in this thread. The one with the broken vase, Murray storming out saying "he couldn't take this shit, etc.." .
KO was not there, but the meeting was the result of the mail he sent on 14th/ 15th june (in Panish's exhibits, and some that I posted earlier today) : first KO sends an email about a stylist to PG, and mentions that Murray didn't allow Michael to come to rehearsals, PG answers his famous "remind him e mail" , KO answers the mail that I posted earlier today : Michael not in shape, needs to be reminded to focus or something like that. That was the 15th.
On 17th, RP sends a mail saying they had a meeting the day before, (16th) to get Mj to focus.
It competely fits with other testimonies, apart from PG who doesn't remember, and it's not clear if Phillips was asked/talked about it.
 
But what about the agreement that Michael had lunch with his children?
.? What agreement? Michael tried to always have meals with his children but there were also times he was occupied by other things he couldn't eat with them. There is the possibility.

School that late in June?? I think Ive read the kids did not have school on June 23/24. The kids followed the curriculum/schedule of a school in LA so its safe to assume their school had ended and they were on summerbreak at that time.
We don't know if Michael asked his children followed the day time class schedule or the complete schedule of school. what I wrote it's just the possible scenario. I find it hard to believe Michael wouldn't let his children study and educate when he was busy with rehearsals. They have tutor.
 
Last edited:
^^

Let me clarify, by evening I tried to mean 1 AM or so before Michael came back from rehearsal. That doesn't seem to fit. An afternoon to evening meeting (anything after noon to 9:00 / 10:00 PM - kids bed time) is possible.

However did they plan to meet at the house? I mean my understanding is Michael woke up around 10:00 to 12:00 in the morning and Murray left the house and he did not come back until late in the night / Michael returned from rehearsal. So even if Phillips stopped by the house in afternoon - evening, Murray should not be at the house. so that's why I asked if this could be an arranged meeting.

and actually guess what June 16th fits, doesn't it? There was a meeting, Michael was out visiting Klein - so fits with Prince calling him - Michael tells Prince to give them snacks and drinks - so it doesn't seem like he's disturbed they are hanging at the house when he's not there meaning he could be expecting them or on his way to come to meet with them - and Michael coming back from Klein and seems not focused ( was that June 16?). So they could have planned to meet at the house. That's why Murray would be there. There could be an exchange with Phillips and Murray at that time. There could be additional talks and that could be why Murray left the meeting saying "I can't take this shit". It fits IMO.

edited to add: Prince said he saw Phillips talk to Murray twice - which could be June 16 and June 20 meetings.
 
It makes perfect sense to me. Prince said Michael ate less meal with them in June. Don't forget although the children were homeschooled, they followed the school schedule strictly. 23th, 24th, Michael rehearsed in staple centre all days. When Michael woke up, his children were in class. when he went home, they slept. So it's quite normal, if prince didnt talk with his father in june 23th. he said it could be 23th, or 24th. He couldn't remember the date but remember it's the last conversation with his father. Latoya's words are the things she heard from the children. what picture of Paris celebration? A cake? What others did for you doesn't mean you want it yourself.

bolded : I think Kai Chase said that too.
 
^^

Let me clarify, by evening I tried to mean 1 AM or so before Michael came back from rehearsal. That doesn't seem to fit. An afternoon to evening meeting (anything after noon to 9:00 / 10:00 PM - kids bed time) is possible.

However did they plan to meet at the house? I mean my understanding is Michael woke up around 10:00 to 12:00 in the morning and Murray left the house and he did not come back until late in the night / Michael returned from rehearsal. So even if Phillips stopped by the house in afternoon - evening, Murray should not be at the house. so that's why I asked if this could be an arranged meeting.

and actually guess what June 16th fits, doesn't it? There was a meeting, Michael was out visiting Klein - so fits with Prince calling him - and Michael coming back from Klein and seems not focused ( was that June 16?). So they could have planned to meet at the house. That's why Murray would be there. There could be an exchange with Phillips and Murray at that time. There could be additional talks and that could be why Murray left the meeting saying "I can't take this shit". It fits IMO.

Yes it does, it can fit with 1 of the 2 incidents Prince was talking about. But Michael was at the riot act meeting, so it would mean they stayed on, or Michael was even in the house, but in another room.

It could also fit with june 20th meeting (and Murray saying Phillips told him about Michael being in big trouble if he didn't do the shows).

For the23rd/24th, I believe it would be after the Kai left, otherwise she would have been asked about it.
 
Karen's email, in a word - WOW!

When she was running her mouth a while back, she apparently forgot to add that HER OWN email confirmations some of AEG'S claims.

Again - WOW!
 
Yes it does, it can fit with 1 of the 2 incidents Prince was talking about. But Michael was at the riot act meeting, so it would mean they stayed on, or Michael was even in the house, but in another room.

It could also fit with june 20th meeting (and Murray saying Phillips told him about Michael being in big trouble if he didn't do the shows).

For the23rd/24th, I believe it would be after the Kai left, otherwise she would have been asked about it.

I edited my post. Prince said he saw Murray and Phillips talk at 2 occasions. Those could be June 16 and June 20.

June 16 Michael was visiting Klein and the testimony we already heard makes it sound like the other people were already in the house when Michael came from Klein and looked not focused and they were told by MAW that he came from Klein.

Also Prince said he called Michael saying people at the house , Michael says "offer them snacks and drinks". That seems like Michael wasn't disturbed with them being at the house, it doesn't seem like it was an unannounced stop by the house or people hanging there when Michael was away. Michael could have been expecting them and/or he could be on his way to home from Klein and he could have said to Prince "offer them snacks and drinks" until he comes back.
 
MJ giving the children money to give to Murray in Vegas AND after, also very interesting.

I had wondered who was holding Murray down while the contract was being put together. And mentioned that in a few of my previous post.
 
I edited my post. Prince said he saw Murray and Phillips talk at 2 occasions. Those could be June 16 and June 20.

June 16 Michael was visiting Klein and the testimony we already heard makes it sound like the other people were already in the house when Michael came from Klein and looked not focused and they were told by MAW that he came from Klein.

Also Prince said he called Michael saying people at the house , Michael says "offer them snacks and drinks". That seems like Michael wasn't disturbed with them being at the house, it doesn't seem like it was an unannounced stop by the house or people hanging there when Michael was away. Michael could have been expecting them and/or he could be on his way to home from Klein and he could have said to Prince "offer them snacks and drinks" until he comes back.
I remember Prince said randy Philips was in this house, what's the "them"? Him!
 
I edited my post. Prince said he saw Murray and Phillips talk at 2 occasions. Those could be June 16 and June 20.

June 16 Michael was visiting Klein and the testimony we already heard makes it sound like the other people were already in the house when Michael came from Klein and looked not focused and they were told by MAW that he came from Klein.

Also Prince said he called Michael saying people at the house , Michael says "offer them snacks and drinks". That seems like Michael wasn't disturbed with them being at the house, it doesn't seem like it was an unannounced stop by the house or people hanging there when Michael was away. Michael could have been expecting them and/or he could be on his way to home from Klein and he could have said to Prince "offer them snacks and drinks" until he comes back.

re june 16th : nobody said Michael was not focused that day? I think Michael could have gone to Klein after the meeting

I think he said offer HIM food, not them ?
 
Last edited:
I checked Klein's records on Panish's website : it doesn't help, it's one page , about things he did in may.
 
24th june Carolwood surveillance cameras :

here is the relevant testimony in CM's trial (Alexander Suppal):
http://www.mjjcommunity.com/forum/t...ct-announced?p=3519555&viewfull=1#post3519555
Gourjian plays a 7 minute video. It’s a camera that looks at the gate. It shows time as 00:45AM. Multiple cars arrive at 00:47AM, 00:50AM and 00:58AM. A car leaves around 01:06 Video shows security guards and fans as well.

Gourjian shows another video. This is from a camera outside on the keypad. It shows 3 cars come in and close up of the driver’s face. It also show the fans waiting outside the street
.

here is the video (relevant part starts at about 1.11

[video=youtube;RWbrX3j0bcA]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWbrX3j0bcA[/video]

you can see 1 car at 00.47 (relatively small car , not Michael )
another car at 00.50 (another relatively small car)
2 bigger cars at 00.58
1 car leaving at 1.06 (relatively small too)

So if Prince was still up when the 1st car arrived, it could match. It would mean RP & Murray met at the house after the rehearsal.
 
I can't believe Katherine's lawyer said he's not sure if Paris would testify and was up to her doctor. So if the doctor says it's ok they will drag her to the stand? WTF?

And Karen Faye, LOL, totally not surprised. She just flushed all her dramatic testimony down the toilet. Her cross tomorrow will definitely be interesting.
 
It makes perfect sense to me. Prince said Michael ate less meal with them in June. Don't forget although the children were homeschooled, they followed the school schedule strictly. 23th, 24th, Michael rehearsed in staple centre all days. When Michael woke up, his children were in class. when he went home, they slept. So it's quite normal, if prince didnt talk with his father in june 23th. he said it could be 23th, or 24th. He couldn't remember the date but remember it's the last conversation with his father. Latoya's words are the things she heard from the children. what picture of Paris celebration? A cake? What others did for you doesn't mean you want it yourself.

The telefon-call obviously wasn`t the last conservation with Michael and I also find at a bit strange that Prince is contradicting himself about this point.


nthony McCartney ?@mccartneyAP 6h

That would rule out June 24th as the day of the tense exchange, but Prince said today he was unclear on which day the exchange happened.


Anthony McCartney ?@mccartneyAP 6h
Putnam showed Prince another portion of his deposition in which he said he talked to his dad the morning after the Phillips/Murray meeting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top