Latest on MJJC

Give your grade for the project 'Michael' the album?

For tabulation purposes, please consider all 10 tracks as a whole when applying a grade for Song Selection and Song Quality rather than apply separate grades for groups of songs. Otherwise it makes it very difficult for the overall calculations.
 
1. Album artwork: F (hate it)
2. Album production: D
3. Album promotion: F
4. Song selection: E
5. Song quality: D (would be much higher if it weren't for you-know-what)

Overall Grade: E
 
1. Album artwork: B+
2. Album production: B-
3. Album promotion: D-
4. Song selection: B-
5. Song quality: A-

Overall Grade: B
 
MattyJam said:
1. Album artwork: F (hate it)
2. Album production: D
3. Album promotion: F
4. Song selection: E
5. Song quality: D (would be much higher if it weren't for you-know-what)

Overall Grade: E
Click to expand...
Thanks for your feedback! For calculation purposes, what does the E grade represent?
 
My grades for the Michael album are as follows:

1. Album artwork:A+
2. Album production:A+
3. Album promotion:A+
4. Song selection:A+
5. Song quality:A+

Overall Grade: A+ :agree:
 
1. Album artwork: A
2. Album production: B+
3. Album promotion: F
4. Song selection: B
5. Song quality: B+

Overall Grade: B
 
CherubimII said:
My grades for the Michael album are as follows:

1. Album artwork:A+
2. Album production:A+
3. Album promotion:A+
4. Song selection:A+
5. Song quality:A+

Overall Grade: A+ :agree:
Click to expand...

Of course, the artwork was outstanding and provided nothing but positive reactions from fans. The production was top notch, almost as if Michael was still here working on it. The promotion has been great, I cant look anywhere without seeing this album being advertised! :O Song selection and quality? 7 are good. That's all i'll say.

This album has pretty much just crumbled, and I think Sony and the Estate have realised it and thats why they have pretty much stopped promotion. Or something has now become apparent to them.
 
donalb said:
Fellow fans, here is your chance to evaluate the project 'Michael' the album. To do so, please indicate a grade of A,B,C,D or F for each of the below subjects. It only takes a second to share your thoughts which will be included in the overall report card. Thanks for your feedback!!!

IMPORTANT: Please do not post specific comments related to the Cascio tracks as we already have several threads dedicated to this subject. Thank you!


Subject (Grade: A,B,C,D,F)

1. Album artwork:
2. Album production:
3. Album promotion:
4. Song selection:
5. Song quality:

Overall Grade:


EDIT: Following, is a cumulative summary of the grades from the data on posts 1-50:

1. Album artwork: C+
2. Album production: C
3. Album promotion: D-
4. Song selection: C-
5. Song quality: B-

Overall Grade: C

I will provide another update once we reach 75 posts. Please continue to provide your report cards. Thanks!
Click to expand...

Just bumping!
 
donalb said:
Thanks for your feedback. And what is your overall grade?
Click to expand...
In addition to your overall grade, could you also please let me know if I should count the E grade for Album Promotion as "D" or "F"? Thanks!
 
L.T.D said:
Of course, the artwork was outstanding and provided nothing but positive reactions from fans. The production was top notch, almost as if Michael was still here working on it. The promotion has been great, I cant look anywhere without seeing this album being advertised! :O Song selection and quality? 7 are good. That's all i'll say.

This album has pretty much just crumbled, and I think Sony and the Estate have realised it and thats why they have pretty much stopped promotion. Or something has now become apparent to them.
Click to expand...

Everyone is entitled to an opinion...please respect that.
 
athina_livadi said:
1. Album artwork: A
2. Album production: A
3. Album promotion: C
4. Song selection: A
5. Song quality: A

Overall Grade: A-
Click to expand...

CherubimII said:
My grades for the Michael album are as follows:

1. Album artwork:A+
2. Album production:A+
3. Album promotion:A+
4. Song selection:A+
5. Song quality:A+

Overall Grade: A+ :agree:
Click to expand...

Athina A-? Why so low, you are a hater compared to Cherubim :D :rofl:
 
1. Album artwork: d
2. Album production: d
3. Album promotion: f
4. Song selection:d
5. Song quality: d
 
1. Album artwork: C (even if i didn't buy it we have a good overview on the internet)
2. Album production: F (because they are 3 fakes and we don't have the original versions of the other songs)
3. Album promotion: U (Unclassified, because it has no importance for a bad product)
4. Song selection: F (because they are 3 fakes)
5. Song quality: F (for the same reason)

Edit : Overall grade : F (the worst mark anyway)
 
1. Album artwork: F
2. Album production: F
3. Album promotion: F (Don't know how in other countries but in Poland there is no any promotion)
4. Song selection: F (Cascio songs...)
5. Song quality: D (some compositons are not bad, they are just very bad produced)

Overall Grade: F
 
StaceyMJ said:
Everyone is entitled to an opinion...please respect that.
Click to expand...

I'm all for respecting people's opinions, however I have to doubt that is someone's true opinion.....

Even if you like the contents of the album, A+ for promotion? Come on, even the biggest supporters of this album have to admit that the promotion has been poor......

I just think Cherubim posted without really thinking too much about it, that's all.
 
1. Album artwork:B
2. Album production:A
3. Album promotion:E
4. Song selection:A+
5. Song quality:A
 
Here is the latest overall summary based on all of the posts so far:

1. Album artwork: C
2. Album production: C
3. Album promotion: D-
4. Song selection: D+
5. Song quality: C+

Overall Grade: C/C-
 
1. Album artwork: A
2. Album production: B
3. Album promotion: B
4. Song selection: B
5. Song quality: A

Overall Grade: B
 
1. Album artwork: B
2. Album production: C
3. Album promotion: F
4. Song selection: C
5. Song quality: B

Overall Grade: C
 
1. Album artwork:B
2. Album production:B
3. Album promotion:F
4. Song selection:B
5. Song quality:B

Overall Grade:B
 
1. Album artwork:A
2. Album production:B+
3. Album promotion D-
4. Song selection:B+
5. Song quality:B
overall: B
 
1. Album artwork:B
2. Album production:D
3. Album promotion:F
4. Song selection:F
5. Song quality:F
Overall: D
 
donalb said:
EDIT: Here is the lastest overall summary as of now:

1. Album artwork: C
2. Album production: C
3. Album promotion: D-
4. Song selection: D+
5. Song quality: C+

Overall Grade: C/C-
Click to expand...

oh.... I agree with this.
there are great songs anyway, but I would say it over and over and yet OVER again: I would have preferred a million times to have the songs just as Michael left them. Just that. Nothing to be added. I have been happy to pay for his unfinished demos before, I will have no problems to pay for new unfished demos again.

As long it is ALL Michael and only Michael.... just as he left it... that's for me :)
 
1. Album artwork: C+
2. Album production: D+
3. Album promotion: F (Fail)
4. Song selection: D-
5. Song quality: C-

Overall Grade: D
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top