Could you show the links for those statements?
Exactly when and where did the brothers say those contradictory things about the magazines?
It's in their court testimonies. Read those parts from Gavin's testimony first, then from Star's and put them next to each other. You will see the difference.
ETA:
Gavin claimed the first occasion happened on the same day they got back from Miami (February 7) and the second occasion about two weeks later. Star claimed the first time happened “after the Calabasas hotel” which would be after March 2 and the second occasion was “a few days later”.
Gavin:
11 Q. Okay. Now, with regard to the first time
12 you saw it downstairs - okay. - in that room that
13 you described where he puts his makeup on, things
14 like that, do you remember whether that occurred
15 before or after Calabasas.
16 A. Well, while we were in there. That was
17 like --
18 Q. The first time.
19 A. Me and Michael only. When he showed me the
20 thing I said about Frank.
21 Q. Right.
22 A. Okay. That was like the same day that we
23 got back -- no.
Yeah, the same night we got back
24 from Miami.
25 Q. All right. What about the second incident
26 where you were upstairs. When was that in
27 relationship to Calabasas.
28 A. A few weeks -- a week later, probably, or 1645
1 two weeks.
Star:
7 Q. Tell us what happened.
8 A. Just walked in the room and it was open. It
9 was -- there used to be a couch right there.
10 Q. Yeah.
11 A. And -- well, it wasn’t really a couch. It
12 was like a chair. And it was on there, and it was
13 open.
14 Q. All right. And then what happened.
15 A. Michael just started to show us magazines.
16 Q. You say “show” you. Tell us what he did.
17 A. He handed them to us.
18 Q. All right. And did you look at them.
19 A. Yes, with him.
20 Q. And did you look at them one at a time or
21 did everybody have a different one at a different
22 time. How did it happen. Tell us what happened.
23 A. We all looked at them one at a time.
24 Q. Did anybody make any comments about
25 anything.
26 A. No.
27 Q. Do you remember how many of them you saw.
28 A. A couple. 1154
1 Q. How long was it that you were there going
2 through them.
3 A. I don’t know. Probably ten minutes.
4 Q. Now, when did that take place, when you saw
5 these for the first -- that suitcase for the first
6 time.
7 A. When.
8 Q. Yeah.
9 A. I think after the Calabasas hotel.
[...]
11 Q. Do you recall how many -- how much time
12 elapsed between the first time you saw the materials
13 downstairs till the time you saw them upstairs.
14 A. A few days.
About the first occasion Gavin claimed that Jackson told them the briefcase that contained the material was Frank Cascio’s and he made fun of Cascio while showing them the magazines. Star claimed Jackson did not make any comments while showing them the material.
Gavin:
9 Q. Now, when you first saw the suitcase, where
10 was it in that room.
11 A. It was next to -- it was to the left of that
12 couch thing.
13 Q. And did you ever see Mr. Jackson pick up the
14 Exhibit 470.
15 A. Yeah, like I was hanging out with him in
16 there, and he was like putting on his makeup or
17 something, I don’t know. And then he -- he grabbed
18 the -- grabbed the suitcase, and then he told me --
19 he told me it was Frank’s. And he showed me, he was
20 like, “This is” --
21 Q. Okay. Well, what did he show you.
22 A. He was, like, “Look at the” -- “Look at this
23 stuff. Frank’s stinking a-s-s.” Frank’s
24 stinking -- it was S- -- Frank’s stinking ass.
25 Q. All right. What was inside the suitcase.
26 A. Adult materials.
Star:
14 Q. All right. And then what happened.
15 A. Michael just started to show us magazines.
16 Q. You say “show” you. Tell us what he did.
17 A. He handed them to us.
18 Q. All right. And did you look at them.
19 A. Yes, with him.
20 Q. And did you look at them one at a time or
21 did everybody have a different one at a different
22 time. How did it happen. Tell us what happened.
23 A. We all looked at them one at a time.
24 Q. Did anybody make any comments about
25 anything.
26 A. No.
About the second occasion Gavin claimed they went through the full content of the briefcase (“we saw, like, practically everything”
and the whole thing lasted about 30 minutes to one hour. Star claimed they saw only about three or four magazines.
Gavin:
16 Q. And do you recall, where in the bedroom was
17 the suitcase when you first saw it that time.
18 A. The first time I saw it, it was in the rest
19 room kind of thing. And then the second time we --
20 I don’t know if we brought it up there or, like,
21 Michael brought it up there or something. I don’t
22 know. But it was up next to his bed. And we were
23 all going through the thing and we were making fun
24 of Frank.
25 Q. Did you look at the magazines.
26 A. Yes.
27 Q. How many magazines do you think you saw.
28 A. We saw, like, practically everything, but 1644
1 there was a few we didn’t look at.
2 Q. How much time do you figure you were looking
3 at all those things.
4 A. 30 minutes to an hour, probably.
5 Q. Did Mr. Jackson make any comments during the
6 time -- other than the ones you’ve talked about, any
7 other comments that he made at any of the
8 photographs or the magazines.
9 A. Not really. We just were, like, making fun
10 of Frank.
Star:
13 Q. And then what.
14 A. He pulled the magazine out and started
15 showing us.
16 Q. How many magazines do you think you saw that
17 time.
18 A. Four. Three. I don’t know.
19 Q. Did you look through the entire magazines.
20 A. No. It was probably a section or something
21 like that.
