IvoryKeys
Proud Member
Hmmm, well I have some "issues" with this list.
But first....
Every time a new poll like this comes out, the lists are never completely fair. And on top of it all, it really is hard to rank such great musical artists from '55 and onward. There are sooo many great rock voices! Someone is gonna get the end of the stick, and some fanbase is gonna be pissed about it. However, I am not implying MJ got the end of the stick in this situation.
These are rock singers. They sing differently. Many of them are technically singing to hurt their voice in the long run. Someone like Robert Plant would technically be singing incorrectly to damage his voice. But he's a rock artist. That's what they do, and that's how they sing to get their emotion across to their audience. Aretha Franklin is a great choice for the best rock singer, I believe. However, I personally believe that 2 particular people should not be on the top 10 that are. I have never really taken a liking to Lennon's voice (and I know many of you will disagree with me on that) and also Bob Dylan. Especially Dylan though. I can't STAND the way he sings. Sure he deserves to be on the list somewhere, BUT NO.7?!?!?!?!
As for Michael....I do kind of wish he was a little higher up on the list. Mostly because he is so versatile. That gritty sound he gets when he sings higher, like in Dirty Diana or Give Into me...I love that, and I think it's very recognizable to other people. But whatev...
But first....
Every time a new poll like this comes out, the lists are never completely fair. And on top of it all, it really is hard to rank such great musical artists from '55 and onward. There are sooo many great rock voices! Someone is gonna get the end of the stick, and some fanbase is gonna be pissed about it. However, I am not implying MJ got the end of the stick in this situation.
These are rock singers. They sing differently. Many of them are technically singing to hurt their voice in the long run. Someone like Robert Plant would technically be singing incorrectly to damage his voice. But he's a rock artist. That's what they do, and that's how they sing to get their emotion across to their audience. Aretha Franklin is a great choice for the best rock singer, I believe. However, I personally believe that 2 particular people should not be on the top 10 that are. I have never really taken a liking to Lennon's voice (and I know many of you will disagree with me on that) and also Bob Dylan. Especially Dylan though. I can't STAND the way he sings. Sure he deserves to be on the list somewhere, BUT NO.7?!?!?!?!
As for Michael....I do kind of wish he was a little higher up on the list. Mostly because he is so versatile. That gritty sound he gets when he sings higher, like in Dirty Diana or Give Into me...I love that, and I think it's very recognizable to other people. But whatev...