Latest on MJJC

Breaking News and Best of Joy : same melodic line (proof it's MJ on BN)

loka

Proud Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2011
Messages
786
Points
0
I just found this while I was listening again and again both tracks


Is It me or there's something similar ?

Best of Joy "1mn10"

I am the one who someday you I will free
Wonder if it seems so hard to be
I am forever, wasn’t it I who carried you around?
When all the words keep turning down


Similar to the chorus of Breaking News ?

Now is that strange that i fall in love
Who is the boogie man you thinkin’ of
All went crazy coz im just in love
This is breaking news This is breaking news
 
Last edited:
Re: Breaking News and Best of Joy : same melodic line (proff it's MJ on BN)

How is this proof????????????????
 
if "best of joy" and "Breaking news" have the same "melodic lines" : it's the proof that MJ made the song Breaking News...Understood ?
 
Why do people keep saying "proof" on thread titles? This is not proof!

And that fact these threads need to be created is a problem in itself.
 
please stay on topic !

is there something similar or not ?
 
loka said:
if "best of joy" and "Breaking news" have the same "melodic lines" : it's the proof that MJ made the song Breaking News...Understood ?
Click to expand...
No way, hahahahaha. Thanks for the laugh. I'm sure you're not being serious, yeah?
 
Pentum said:
No way, hahahahaha. Thanks for the laugh. I'm sure you're not being serious, yeah?
Click to expand...

once again : if a cascio track of 2007 has some similar melodic lines than a 100 % MJ track like "best of joy" made in 2009, it's the proof that the same Man has done these 2 tracks ...and guess who is it ?

It's important to stay on this topic and to find if there are similarities or not in these songs.
 
You should be a lawer. :lol:

I think it is MJ on BN, but this shows nothing.
 
Hess said:
You should be a lawer. :lol:

I think it is MJ on BN, but this shows nothing.
Click to expand...

would you call this similarities a coincidence ?

if there is a similaritie, it's certainly not a coincidence


what I've found could be very very very important.

don't take it like a joke please. Stay aware and listen. Thanks
 
Similarities are not the same as proof :cheeky: and it's also not our job to prove if Michael is singing those songs or not... Enjoy the music and let the people who have any real proof do that...
 
I am sorry, i try to stay serious and ontopic. But this is just good for a much needed laugh, i thank you for that. Honestly...no offense. But no i don't see any similarities, this really is nothing if you ask me.
 
Staffordshire Bullterrier said:
I am sorry, i try to stay serious and ontopic. But this is just good for a much needed laugh, i thank you for that. Honestly...no offense. But no i don't see any similarities, this really is nothing if you ask me.
Click to expand...

thanks for the effort

once again try to forget the words and listen only the global melody

in these 2 parts of the tracks

thanks again
 
athina_livadi;3132771 said:
The album is out so let's enjoy it no matter what!
Click to expand...

some fans need proof and i need them to.

Perhaps I just found it !

If anybody can help (musician ?), it would be nice


Best of Joy "1mn10"

I am the one who someday you I will free
Wonder if it seems so hard to be, people they wanna hurt you
I am forever, wasn’t it I who carried you around ?*
When all the words keep turning down


Similar to the chorus of Breaking News ?

Now is that strange that i fall in love
Who is the boogie man you thinkin’ of
All went crazy coz im just in love
This is breaking news This is breaking news
 
Lets be polite here.

Nobody is really doubting MJ wrote the songs. People just dont think is him singing on the songs.

This isnt really proof that he wrote them either though, but I dont think anybody is really disupting whether he wrote them or not.
 
L.T.D said:
Lets be polite here.

Nobody is really doubting MJ wrote the songs. People just dont think is him singing on the songs.

This isnt really proof that he wrote them either though, but I dont think anybody is really disupting whether he wrote them or not.
Click to expand...

you're right !

as soon as i heard the bridge of BN which is great, I knew that MJ wrote the track

and what I've found could be another proof !

it's important to agree that MJ is the writer of the track before discussing of the voice

if he's the writter, he can be indeed the singer...(you follow me ?)
 
loka said:
you're right !

as soon as i heard the bridge of BN which is great, I knew that MJ wrote the track

and what I've found could be another proof !

it's important to agree that MJ is the writer of the track before discussing of the voice

if he's the writter, he can be indeed the singer...(you follow me ?)
Click to expand...

I do follow you. I'm not totally sure this is proof that MJ wrote it though.

But nobody has really disputed that. I think the general outlook on things from the side of the doubters has been that MJ wrote the songs and either didnt get a chance to record them, or just partially recorded them. Then the rest was filled in with an imposter.

Or am I wrong? Are there those here who dont think MJ even wrote the songs? I did have my doubts at first with Breaking News, due to the fact his own name is included in the lyrics. But i'm pretty sure he had wrote them now.

dangerous_88 said:
what does loka mean again? :)
Click to expand...

I think it means 'crazy'
 
L.T.D;3132805 said:
I do follow you. I'm not totally sure this is proof that MJ wrote it though.


Or am I wrong? Are there those here who dont think MJ even wrote the songs? .
Click to expand...


a lot of fans believe that the Cascio songs are 100 % fake...


that's why i made this topic : it's a kind of "musicology topic"...you know what I mean...

But i'm not a musician and i hope that a musician here will help me.



Best of Joy "1mn10"
I am the one who someday you I will free
Wonder if it seems so hard to be, people they wanna hurt you
I am forever, wasn’t it I who carried you around ?*
When all the words keep turning down


Similar to the Chorus of Breaking News ?

Now is that strange that i fall in love
Who is the boogie man you thinkin’ of
All went crazy coz im just in love
This is breaking news This is breaking news
 
so this part of Best of Joy is just slower than the part of Breaking News

I'm talking about the melody

Best of Joy "1mn10"
I am the one who someday you I will free
Wonder if it seems so hard to be, people they wanna hurt you
I am forever, wasn’t it I who carried you around ?*
When all the words keep turning down



Chorus of Breaking News ?

Now is that strange that i fall in love
Who is the boogie man you thinkin’ of
All went crazy coz im just in love
This is breaking news This is breaking news
 
Do you really think that melodic line proofs that it's Michael?

Eh, I'd say the vocals can tell it is Michael if it is.
 
loka;3132836 said:
so this part of Best of Joy is just slower than the part of Breaking News

I'm talking about the melody

Best of Joy "1mn10"
I am the one who someday you I will free
Wonder if it seems so hard to be, people they wanna hurt you
I am forever, wasn’t it I who carried you around ?*
When all the words keep turning down



Chorus of Breaking News ?

Now is that strange that i fall in love
Who is the boogie man you thinkin’ of
All went crazy coz im just in love
This is breaking news This is breaking news
Click to expand...


Nobody said this yet, but why do you keep repeating the same thing over and over again? I swear i've seen this exact message three or four times now?
 
It is Michael but I think this has even less proof than my thread. I don't understand what the similar melodies have to do with the thing who recorded the song. Someone writes the song, someone records it and someone mixes it. Only if Michael was the one and only person working on the song like from the start to the end it would be a proof.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top