Just finished it, and it’s definitely a mixed bag.
The handling of the unseen footage was great. Nelson doesn’t dangle it in front of your face for all of two seconds; he offers extended glances, all of which were superb. The production values and editing were also top notch; it felt like money was spent getting this thing put together.
Still, it’s not perfect. As always, the contemporary talking heads were overused and extraneous. They should have been saved for a prologue or epilogue, if at all. The direction was all over the place; we shift from a chronological timeline to random interjections from Polo G, BTS, and TikTok (which, again, emphasize that there should’ve been a segment dedicated solely to the album’s enduring influence and popularity). Also, I understand that it’s simply impossible to obtain the source footage for every single clip… but could we do better than YouTube rips? At least one literally had a watermark in the top corner, lmfao.
Overall, I’d rank this above Spike’s documentaries in damn near every category. It’s a good starting point for newcomers, and there’s enough new material to at least keep the longtime fans interested. But when you’re memorializing the best-selling album in world history, “it’s good” ain’t gonna fully cut it.
I’d give it a 6.5/10. If more docs are in the cards, I hope a completely new director gets a shot.