HIStoric
Proud Member
- Joined
- Apr 12, 2011
- Messages
- 3,456
- Points
- 48
Re: Worst song lyrics ever
I'm not...?
You sound too critical towards British people.
I'm not...?
You sound too critical towards British people.
I'm not...?
I cannot understand why you criticize the Western people, particularly the British ones, & their traditions.
...I'm not? What are you going on about?
My question aims generally at such songs interpretations.
It looks like that some songs (for example, particular Christmas songs) try to make Western people feel some sort of shame (during certain festive occasions) because of the permanent, dire African situation.
HIStoric;4191672 said:Well I wasn't criticising British people/Westerners, if that's what you're wondering. I don't think Westerners who are better off should feel shame because they are... if anything I think that's silly actually.
HIStoric;4191672 said:As someone who is quite privileged in a sense (especially compared to the Africans affected by famine as mentioned in the song), sometimes I/we do take our lifestyle for granted. Every once in a while it doesn't hurt to be reminded that ya know, there are people out there who are less fortunate so we should be grateful. I don't feel shameful because I'm better off and I'm not going to, but I do recognise that I'm lucky to be born into the situation that I am in and so I'm grateful for that.
Doesn't that just mean "there, but for the Grace of God, go I?" It could very well be them. It could very well be me. In other words, it's compassion and empathy.-_- And wtf is with the "thank God it's them instead of you", who says that in a charity song?
MichaelD;4191717 said:I wonder why this hasn't been brought up already
Everybody wanting a piece of Michael Jackson
Reporters stalking the moves of Michael Jackson
(...)
Everybody watching the news on Michael Jackson
They wanna see that I fall cause I'm Michael Jackson
mj_frenzy;4191675 said:Seriously, do you believe that the song ‘Do They Know It’s Christmas’ genuinely aimed at raising awareness?
This goes back to an interesting discussion we had some months ago (when you seemed to be positive about such recordings).
barbee0715;4191707 said:Yes, these songs do create good publicity for the involved artists, but there are actually people out there who want to help and encourage others to help their fellow man.
The song's target audience seems to primarily be a Western audience who experience snowfall during Christmas, and thus they often identify Christmas with snow, so the visual image of a lack of snow maybe helps emphasise how "un-Christmas" it is to them. I've seen comments online from Americans/British people saying it's weird to see places like Australia and NZ have super hot summers on Christmas day, simply they're so used it to be freezing cold and snowy.
However, wasn't this song written for and during a huge famine? Therefore being a famine, many riverbeds are drying up, there's no rainfall and therefore many crops are failing to grow? I mean, if that's the case then the lyrics fit....?
Doesn't that just mean "there, but for the Grace of God, go I?" It could very well be them. It could very well be me. In other words, it's compassion and empathy.
I'm not a cynical person who questions the intent or value of songs like this. I think it's great when artists use their platform to raise money or awareness for a good causeIs the thread about songs that have aged and are now cringeworthy, or always had bad lyrics?The lyrics may have been appropriate for that specific time and place but that doesn't mean it's not cringeworthy today. And that's all this thread is about, right?
Well, and maybe I'm misunderstanding the lyric-but I always took it to mean what I said about "there, but for the Grace of God, go I?" In other words, the famine could just as easily occur in England. We could be homeless if our company goes under. We are one disease away from being bankrupt and on the street.and I'm sure this song (and others like them) helped a lot of people. That's beside the point. I just wish that this particular song didn't include such sweeping generalisations of an entire continent. I understand the need to describe Africa in the most dire terms in order to convince people to donate their money or time but I also feel bad for Africans who take pride in their cultural Christmas traditions that this song comes back on the radio every year, removed from the context of a famine.
It's compassion and empathy to thank God it's them and not you?
So, you thank God for your blessings, and help those more unfortunate. They're no different than you and it could be you tomorrow.We are all one.
Maybe that's just a naive assumption on my part, and since I know the song was written for the famine, I hear it that way. Granted, I'm not as familiar with it as people in the UK (and I guess Europe and Africa) are. They rarely play it here at Christmas, and even in 85, it didn't seem to be played much.
Is the thread about songs that have aged and are now cringeworthy, or always had bad lyrics?
Well, and maybe I'm misunderstanding the lyric-but I always took it to mean what I said about "there, but for the Grace of God, go I?" In other words, the famine could just as easily occur in England. We could be homeless if our company goes under. We are one disease away from being bankrupt and on the street.
So, you thank God for your blessings, and help those more unfortunate. They're no different than you and it could be you tomorrow.We are all one.
Maybe that's just a naive assumption on my part, and since I know the song was written for the famine, I hear it that way. Granted, I'm not as familiar with it as people in the UK (and I guess Europe and Africa) are. They rarely play it here at Christmas, and even in 85, it didn't seem to be played much.
You're 100% correct Barbee.
Is the thread about songs that have aged and are now cringeworthy, or always had bad lyrics?
So, you thank God for your blessings, and help those more unfortunate. They're no different than you and it could be you tomorrow.We are all one.
That song was a hit for Louis Jordan before it was used in Tom & JerryI remember that tom and jerry episode hahaha We have it on video
I've always loved that song.That song was a hit for Louis Jordan before it was used in Tom & Jerry