OnirMJ
Proud Member
- Joined
- Apr 13, 2010
- Messages
- 6,485
- Points
- 83
And those contemporized versions aren't Michael's music, he had nothing to do with instrumentation and mixing.
Opinions. Everyone has one!
Still it's MJ's music.
And those contemporized versions aren't Michael's music, he had nothing to do with instrumentation and mixing.
How dare they use MJ's music to co promote another MJ related project... oh wait.. never mind. gotta love MJ fans love of drama though.
Use of remix/new version could be due to their attempt to chart the song. streaming of both videos will count towards the same version of the song.
and when did the new versions became not MJ's music? Just because they changed the packaging it doesn't mean it's not mj's music imo.
They are not remixes, they are album versions. Like this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwfuxJGrAO8
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c-DyQ268AFs
That was finished song but MJ and Teddy Riley decided to contemporize it. Because MJ & Bill Bottrell's version was not "current enough".
Maybe MJ did not create any part of the new instrumentation but MJ vocals guided (influenced) StarGate to create new instrumentation around those vocals. And it's not just the vocals, it's the melody, it's the song (not instrumentation and not production) that is the same.
I think anyone who says they are as much Michael's songs as the ones he released in his life deludes himself.
I never said that. I said:
1. Those songs ARE still MJ's music
2. Those songs are NOT remixes
Posthumous releases and posthumous songs should be considered for what they are and should not be compared with songs MJ finished and released himself.
But they ARE remixes. To act like they aren't just because they get a stamp as "official" is a delusion IMO. They got that stamp from MJ's Estate (lawyers) and not from the artist himself.
Way to much over analizing over this. They did a fine job with this. If we keep complaining about everything it makes us Mj fans look ungrateful and a bit selfish. Perfection was Mj he is not here anymore. It will never be the same again. I for one am grateful for there efforts and look forward to future project." This is the place that you choose to be". Enjoy and celebrate the man and his music.
This is hilarious really, most all the posters that don't like the video never really liked Xscape in the first place. So why even argue with them when they have never liked anything from this project from the beginning. It is fruitless.
The contemporized version isn't Michael's music. He had nothing to do with the creation of it. Only the vocals are Michael's in that version, in my opinion of course.
I never said that. I said:
1. Those songs ARE still MJ's music
2. Those songs are NOT remixes
Posthumous releases and posthumous songs should be considered for what they are and should not be compared with songs MJ finished and released himself.
Comments are disabled for the video.
What a cheap and pathetic video
OnirMJ;4039489 said:Positive article by ****** *******:
http://www.*************.com/michael-jackson-one-apwnn-video/
Edit
Roger Friedman
This is disgusting, very sad, pathetic and little scary to me that D.a.m.i.e.n S.h.i.e.l.d.s' (a fan, fighter against fake songs, a lot of times credible source, the guy who wrote some brilliant articles about unreleased MJ songs...) name is banned here, but the name of one of the biggest scums on the face of the Earth, one of the biggest MJ haters in the world, a liar, the guy who was paid to lie about fake songs... his name is not banned here on MJ forum???
UNBELIEAVABLE!!!
I say to whoever did this, unban Damiens's name (the only thing he ever did wrong was to often write his own opinions as facts - like that Xscape 2.0 article - but that's nothing compared to what Roger Friedman wrote) or ban Roger "the Cascio lover"'s name!
qbee;4039491 said:The project was not commissioned by Sony Music or The Estate of Michael Jackson, therefore was done without a budget. Essentially it’s a labour of love on the part of the Cirque show’s cast, who did everything on their own.
Lol the guy actually presses the play button of the Original version in his phone but the new version starts playing in the video.
I don't think it is disrespecting the old version, they just used that part to fit the opening scene, in the desert and all with the guy lazily playing the guitar. I actually liked the choreography in this one.
Videos like these makes me want to get out and take up a course in animation. I wish I could bring out the images in my head I have for this song.
The comments are disabled for the video. The estate is definitely reading our threads. :bugeyed