"but her exact quote "I thought Doctors like priests took an oath of confidentiality" is exactly the same"
You changed it now in your original post, but it wasn't exactly the same. It was rather a reflection on what YOU made out of that quote in your mind than what it really was originally.
"why she couldn't simply make it easier just to say quote "Dr. Klein is a disgraceful liar, Michael was NOT gay and he should be ashamed of betraying Michael with these lies"
Again, you have to understand Elizabeth Taylor won't say anything that would make the impression she had a problem with homosexuality. When someone gets too defensive about someone not being gay people might get that impression. I often experienced that myself. When someone says Michael was gay and I say no, he wasn't, haters often turn it around and twist it and say I only say that because I'm a homophobe. I'm not a homophobe, I'm a lie-phobe. Hell, didn't Alicia Jacobs, who broke the Pfeiffer story, say MJ fans are homophobes, because they tweeted to her and told her he wasn't gay? And she turned it around and said how MJ fans should be happy that MJ was happy and how they are homophobes for not accepting the Pfeiffer story as true.
Also like Pace said above this is the way Elizabeth talked and you have to understand British sarcasm.
"I mean the "priest" quote dosen't make sence, you go to a priest to confess your inner secrets and sins knowing that the priest under the eyes of god will never be able to repeat anything you've told them, so when she says that, it states that Michael made confessions to Dr. Klein and he betrayed his "confidence" by revealing it... seriously for one second look at this thinking this is not about Michael and Liz... you guys don't find that quote truly twisted... it's as if my right now my dentist tells everyone I just murdered someone and in my defence my best friend quotes on her twitter acount "This dentist should be ashamed, I thought you doctors were like priests!" what would everyone say there?"
Murder is not the same as homosexuality. You don't have to have a problem with homosexuality, while you should have a problem with murder. Again: the way Elizabeth tweeted it was to say she wouldn't have a problem with it IF Michael had a homosexual relationship, her problem is with Klein's behaviour.
Also I feel you take this one sentence with the priests and confidentiality oath out of context and harp on it, while forgetting the rest which clearly indicated her sarcasm and her disbelief of the story. I say "disbelief" and not "knowledge" because to me this tweet also indicates she didn't really have any knowledge about it. Probably that's another reason why she wasn't in the position to say: "it's a lie". How could she be 100% sure? She could only express her opinion and feelings which were - judging from her sarcasm -clearly that she didn't believe it.
Honestly, I don't know the nature of the friendship between Michael and Elizabeth in terms of whether Michael confined in her about his sexual life. Maybe he didn't. You can have a deep, long-running friendship without that ever being a topic between you.
Maybe he did and he did tell her from time to time that he wasn't gay. Still, human sexuality is a rather flexible thing. Sometimes straight people try homosexual sex. I'm not saying Michael did and I definitely don't believe for a moment that Michael had anything with Pfeiffer. The story is just ridiculous, he and Klein weren't even able to get their story straight and corroborate with each other.
I'm only saying that straight people sometimes try homosexual sex to try to put Elizabeth's behaviour in a perspective for you - and to try to explain why she might not have been in the position to state for 100% it's a lie. It's simply because you can never be sure about what other people are doing in their bed. Do you know that her big love, Richard Burton sometimes had sex with men (he said that in an interview)? Human sexuality is not all that black or white and Elizabeth knew that very well.
Again I emphasize: I don't say this to suggest Michael did this too and I'm very sure Pfeiffer's story is nothing but a lie. It's so ridiculous. I just say it to try to help you to understand why Elizabeth might have chosen to say this rather than to flat out saying: "it's a lie, leave him alone".
Why dosen't she state that these are "lies" but a instead a "betrayal of trust"... and I'm not the one who's making it a big deal, I don't know about America, but here in France this story was a laughing joke until she made those twitts and all of the frendh media posted everywhere "Liz Taylor Outs Her Friend Michael, Could It Be True That Michael Was Gay?", and especially knowing the ampler that her statement was taking with the press and non fans why not twitt a statement clearing the matter up?
The French media need seriously to take comprehension lessons then and not taking things out of context. I haven't seen Elizabeth "outing" Michael anywhere. Sometimes those journalists are gay themselves and they want celebrities to be gay as well. Ian Halperin is gay and his website is all about "this celebrity is gay, that celebrity is gay". The woman (Alicia Jacobs) who interviewed Pfeiffer is an outspoken gay advocate. So there you see a motivation by some people in the media why they are desperate to paint Michael gay. They don't seem to understand what's the problem with it. Instead they call everybody who has a problem with it "homophobe".
I have to say they do the gay community a disservice by this IMO. I'm all for gay rights but when they make up lies about other people it makes them look bad and desperate. I wish gay people (and their advocates) wouldn't try to vindicate themselves by gossiping and making up lies about other people's sexuality. It doesn't look good for them.
BTW, I remember when the story broke Joseph was asked about it too by TMZ and he got very angry and told it was a lie. But he also said that doctors take a confidentiality oath so Klein should shut up. It's not to indicate Klein really knows the things he is talking about either in Joe's or Elizabeth's case. It's just their way of telling him to shut up and stop talking to the press about Michael - regardless of if the informations he has to offer on Michael are true or false (and the Pfeiffer story is obviously false).
"and for the past few months after the research I had done on her I had this feel that she was a complete backstabber with the rest of them... "
No, she wasn't a backstabber. Far from it.
