i wish i got here earlier. i don't think i can add anything that hasn't already been stated
to answer the question, i'll quote michael himself; 'there is no formula that i know of'. you can create a strategy, but there's no guarantee of what the outcome will be. michael initially declined the offer to take part in the' motown 25th anniversary special'. his record label had no interest in releasing/financing a third video/short film ('thriller'). in fact, michael was without a manager for most of 1983 :O it was film that he intended to focus on that year. most biographies released around this time spoke of an upcoming 'peter pan' movie, directed by steven spielberg. michael was also due back in the studio with his brothers to record a long awaited follow up to their 1980 'triumph' album. however, the hits from 'thriller' kept on rolling - which prevented that. each single, video, performance, award, was an event that added to the album sales, and sustained the era for three years. the album even re-entered the uk charts in 1988 to compete with his current release. it was still being nominated for awards in 1986.
at the root of it all was the music itself. 'billie jean' had already reached the top of the charts on both sides of the atlantic, before the mtv played it. 'thriller' was already the biggest selling solo, non soundtrack album of all time before there was a film. that film went on to create a record for home video music cassettes, by being the best selling, despite the ceasing of distribution.
the success of 'thriller' was revenge for 'off the wall' being snubbed by the grammy's. michael was determined to not be labelled an r&b/disco artist. he expanded his sound whilst remaining true to those roots. he was able to reach everyone that way. it's still his most popular album. artists such as the weeknd, dua lipa, and bruno mars, are still trying to imitate it.
Yes to all of this. Yes, yes, yes to all of this.
But ... (you knew there was a 'but' coming, didn't you?)
This is all good stuff and I'm not meaning to dismiss it at all but what I was trying (and utterly failing) to capture was just the earth-shattering, unexpected, mind-blowing effect of Michael's Motown 25 performance. Because I have no writing talent or ability to analyse stuff I can't say what I want to say. It's so frustrating. But I was trying to paint a picture where it's understood that we all knew how phenomenal Thriller already was at that point; I mean, the album was crushing everything in sight. Billie Jean's video had already become a 'thing', it was so successful and so different. The MTV hoo - ha was already sorted. Beat It just blew everything out of the water with the concept, the dancing, the choreography etc. So a person (not you, just some random person) might ask, 'well, what's the big deal with this Motown thing?' That's the bit I can't describe. It was a mind-blowing performance *in spite* of everything that Michael had already achieved, in spite of Thriller just going off like a firework display. It wasn't a case of, 'oh here's the next cool thing that Michael Jackson is going to do, pass the popcorn'.
It was like, 'oh you think Michael Jackson is brilliant? Just watch this'.
Let me try again. Michael explodes out of the toaster at the beginning of his Dangerous shows. That's how explosive the Motown thing was. For me, at least. Other people will remember it differently, of course. But, for me, it turned my brain inside out.
I don't think I even watched it for Michael, I'm not sure but I think I just watched it cos I loved Motown. I don't remember Michael's performance with the brothers, or anybody else for that matter, not even my beloved Temptations. I only remember Michael. Everything just sort of crystallised around those few golden minutes. That and then the immortal Fred Astaire quote a few days later.
None of us knew at the time that Michael didn't wanna do the Motown thing. Which is kind of hilarious. Because it's now so iconic and important, not just in Michael's career and legacy but as a stand-out, unmatched, historic tv moment. Just beautiful.