We’ve Had Enough vs Earth Song

[filmandmusic]

Both songs are undeniably epic in scope and sound but which one do you prefer.

You have to have an open mind when voting. Don’t think of Earth song as the Christmas nr 1 hit with epic video as it would be unfair to WHE which is only a track from the vaults.

What song has the best vocals, lyrics and production?

 

[zinniabooklover]

No contest. WHE

"Why did you do it?
Please don't do it
Why did you do it?"

 

[Hollywood_Tonight]

Easy. "Earth Song". MJ's vocal performance is killer- maybe even his best vocal of all time. I like "We've Had Enough", but the climax was clearly inspired by "Earth Song".

 

[Spaceship]

Ultimately, "We've Had Enough" is a poor man's "Earth Song". Still a fine song and should have been on Invincible.

 

[Blues_Away2023]

Earth song is a MJ classic. Massive monster hit in Europe, 6 weeks number 1 in UK.

It feels original and unlike we've had enough which was a lesser attempt and making another ES.

I love both but Earth Song is my favourite.

 

[Michaels Lover]

Earth Song