VOTE: Katy Perry’s “Last Friday Night” Vs. Michael Jackson’s “Dirty Diana”: The Quest For #1

Moonwalker.Fan

Proud Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2011
Messages
3,584
Points
0
Location
Slovakia
Katy Perry’s “Last Friday Night” Vs. Michael Jackson’s “Dirty Diana”: The Quest For #1



Following the single release of Katy Perry’s “Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.)” — which arrived on the heels of her previous four #1 hits off Teenage Dream — chart watchers have been wondering one thing: will the Smurfy songstress be the first artist to match Michael Jackson’s record streak of five consecutive Billboard Hot 100 #1s from album (1987’s Bad)?

It’s looking that way: this week Perry’s latest radio staple inches up to #2 on the chart. Let’s take a closer look at what made “Dirty Diana,” Michael’s fifth Bad smash, tick, and decide if Katy’s has what it takes to repeat the late pop legend’s feat.
First of all, when Jackson’s Bad was released late in the summer of 1987, it hit music buyers with the strength of the singer’s Siedah Garrett duet “I Just Can’t Stop Loving You” behind it. The tender love jam soared to #1, and it was followed by a steady flow of equally-successful tunes from the King Of Pop’s seventh studio album: “Bad,” “The Way You Make Me Feel,” “Man In The Mirror” and “Dirty Diana.”
Thus, Michael became the first artist in Hot 100 history to rack up five #1s off one album.
So just what amazing pop elements were mixed together to concoct MJ’s record-setting smash?

“DIRTY DIANA”


Writers:
Michael Jackson
Producers: Quincy Jones, Michael Jackson
Type of song: Slinky, slow-grinding hard-rock ballad.
Lyrical theme: A wanton groupie wants to pounce on Michael and make him sha-moan! Can he resist her vixen charms? Eeeeeeeeee-HEEEEEEE!!!
Unique elements: Skull-crunching heavy metal guitar solo and recurring licks by Married To Rock star Steve Stevens.
Sample lyric: “She’s saying that’s okay, hey baby do what you want / I’ll be your night-lovin’ thing, I’ll be the freak you can taunt.”
Climate of #1 singles in 1988: The three chart-toppers that preceded “Dirty Diana” were George Michael’s ballad “One More Try,” Rick Astley’s high-octane pop confection “Together Forever” and Debbie Gibson’s somber tearjerker “Foolish Beat.”
Our two cents: Michael was in firmly perched up high in his ’80s imperial phase by this point, but we’re not so sure the cheesy chintz of “Dirty Diana” holds up when compared to, say, the surprisingly-lower-charting “Smooth Criminal” (a #7 hit).


Now let’s shift to Katy Perry’s follow-up to her string of four #1s (”California Gurls,” “Teenage Dream,” “Firework” and “E.T.”):
“LAST FRIDAY NIGHT (T.G.I.F.)”




Writers:
Katy Perry, Lukasz Gottwald (aka Dr. Luke), Max Martin, Bonnie McKee
Producers: Dr. Luke, Max Martin
Type of song: No-holds-barred pop with dance and rock elements.
Lyrical theme: Uh-oh! Katy got way toasted at a rager and can’t remember exactly what or who she did — or how many! Someone needs a cold compress and a Bloody Mary ASAP.
Unique elements: Nostalgic sax solo by the Saturday Night Live Band’s Lenny Pickett.
Sample lyric: “Pictures of last night ended up online, I’m screwed, oh well / It’s a blacked-out blur but I’m pretty sure it ruled — DAMN!”
Climate of #1 singles in 2011: The last three #1s on the Hot 100 have been Adele’s juggernaut “Rolling In The Deep,” Pitbull’s lusty “Give Me Everything” and LMFAO’s global dance hit “Party Rock Anthem.”
Our two cents: Next to “Teenage Dream,” this is our fave cut on Perry’s album. The clever, John Hughes-esque video alone makes this a total hit in our eyes!
Now have your say:
Do you think Katy Perry deserves to tie Michael Jackson's chart record of five #1 singles from one album?


VOTE HERE - http://idolator.com/5953712/katy-perry-michael-jackson
 
*Sigh*

The media are trying hard tp push her to "match" MJ, don't they?

When I saw the title of this thread I thought it's a joke. I mean it is a joke even to ask this question. It's as if they asked who is better, the Beatles or Justin Bieber. Seriously.
 
Thats why its important to support Michael, and show the media (and the readers) that MJ has the strong support and with commenting such articles we can "do something" for MJ, who else?

The media obssession with "who is better than MJ" simply emphasizes the interest for a song that wouldnt be normally recognized by most of the people, but with the connection with MJ..., its different...
 
I have noticed something. The press always compares and mentiones MJ with artists that are not up to his standards. No offence to Justin Bieber fans, but everytime that they mention JB they will stick MJ's name next to him. Same thing here with Katie Perrie or this kind of artist out there. I haven't see do that with other artists. Would they compare Katie Berrie with, lets say ,Elvis Presley? No.Why they do that to Michael? If order to reduce his importance as an artist?Imo, yes, that's why they do it.
 
Oh no, not this crap again. I thought her single had dropped. WTF? Some people are so intent on having MJ's records broken. In any case she will ONLY be matching Michael's record NOT breaking it. So...
 
how on earth can they even compare Dirty Diana with Last Friday Night???????????? smh
 
I have noticed something. The press always compares and mentiones MJ with artists that are not up to his standards. No offence to Justin Bieber fans, but everytime that they mention JB they will stick MJ's name next to him. Same thing here with Katie Perrie or this kind of artist out there. I haven't see do that with other artists. Would they compare Katie Berrie with, lets say ,Elvis Presley? No.Why they do that to Michael? If order to reduce his importance as an artist?Imo, yes, that's why they do it.


I agree. By comparing him to the likes of Justin Bieber, Katy Perry etc. they want to send out the message that Michael is in the same category.

I have to say though that sometimes they do it to other legends as well. For example back in the 90s I have seen articles comparing Take That to the Beatles (in terms of mass hysteria etc)...
 
orz
Even Katy did get the fifth number 1. She is no way to compare with MJ.
They should start to discuss this, if she is still on top in the industry in 10 years.
Katy had many good songs but I just can't see how this song can compare with dirty Diana.
Of course, this is just my opinion.
 
I smell a hater:

Dirty Diana: Our two cents: Michael was in firmly perched up high in his ’80s imperial phase by this point, but we’re not so sure the cheesy chintz of “Dirty Diana” holds up when compared to, say, the surprisingly-lower-charting “Smooth Criminal” (a #7 hit).

Last Friday Night: Our two cents:Next to “Teenage Dream,” this is our fave cut on Perry’s album. The clever, John Hughes-esque video alone makes this a total hit in our eyes!

this is as ridiculous as the poll asking "is JB the next KOP?" :doh:
 
This is like comparing Mount Everest to a pile of dirt.

:doh:
 
Back
Top