Uhm, I had to go with It's ok. I don't love it because it's obviously not the best in terms of quality or even dialogues or story. But I believe, not being biased, that Michael was the best by far. He nailed the scarecrow and it's mainly because he made it different, groovy and funky. I love that, and Ease on Down is just perfect.
I believe we're not being biased in here. Even the critics agreed it was a failure that couldn't recover the $24 millions budget and made in the box office $13,600 millions.
Critical reception
Critics panned
The Wiz upon its October 1978 release. Many reviewers directed their criticism at Diana Ross,
who they believed was too old to play Dorothy (I totally agree, she didn't look like a young girl at all.) Most agreed that what had worked so successfully on stage simply didn't translate well to the screen. Hischak's
Through the Screen Door: What Happened to the Broadway Musical When It Went to Hollywood criticized "Joel Schumacher's cockamamy screenplay," and called "Believe in Yourself" the score's weakest song. He described Diana Ross's portrayal of Dorothy as: "
cold, neurotic and
oddly unattractive" (I agree with the bolded parts I made
and noted that the film was "a critical and box office bust." In his work
History of the American Cinema, Harpole characterized the film as "one of the decade's biggest failures," and, "the year's biggest musical flop."
The Grove Book of Hollywood noted that "the picture finished off Diana Ross's screen career," as the film was Ross's final theatrical feature. In his book
Blockbuster, Tom Shone referred to
The Wiz as "expensive crud." In the book
Mr. and Mrs. Hollywood, the author criticized the script, noting, "
The Wiz was too scary for children, and too silly for adults." Ray Bolger,who played the Scarecrow in the 1939
The Wizard of Oz film, did not think highly of
The Wiz, stating, "
The Wiz is overblown and will never have the universal appeal [the 1939 film] has obtained."
Michael Jackson's performance as the Scarecrow was one of the only positively reviewed elements of the film, with critics noting that Jackson possessed "genuine acting talent" and "provided the only genuinely memorable moments." (I couldn't agree more, totally true.)
If The Wiz was a good movie, it hadn't had such negative critiques and it'd had made even more money at the box office! Michael is the only gem of it! I don't get why Michael didn't have more acting opportunities, he's not a bad actor at all, no matter what some people have said like J. Randy Taraborrelli. "Janet has what Michael is lacking, acting skills." :wtf2: